Skip to main content
67ink.com

By color

HP 67 tri-color: 3YM55AN or 3YM58AN?

The tri-color cartridge holds cyan, magenta and yellow in one body, in standard (3YM55AN) and XL (3YM58AN).

Content updated:

Standard or XL tri-color

FeatureHP 67 tri-colorHP 67XL tri-color
Part number3YM55AN3YM58AN
Stated yield (HP)approx. 100 pagesapprox. 200 pages
Lowest checked price$23.89 (Staples)$36.89 (Staples)
Cost per page now23.9¢18.4¢

The retailer shown comes first in the ranking (by price including shipping when every priced retailer's shipping is known); the price shown excludes shipping and sales tax.

One body for three colors

You can't replace cyan, magenta and yellow separately. Photos or pages dominated by one color can empty one chamber before the others; you still replace the whole cartridge.

When does tri-color XL make sense?

Choose XL if you print in color regularly and want to change less often. Standard can be enough if you rarely use color — also bear in mind how long an opened cartridge sits unused in the printer.

Faded or missing colors

Check the seating and the error message first. Run only the maintenance step your printer manual describes; repeated cleaning uses ink itself.

Prices by retailer

HP 67 tri-color (3YM55AN)

Comparison of 3 retailers with a checked price. Shipping is unknown for at least one retailer, so the ranking uses the product price before shipping. Prices are before sales tax, which depends on your state.
  1. Staples Original HP Lowest checked product price

    Checked yesterday: September 27, 2026

    $23.89

    Shipping unknown

    23.9¢/page

    View offer
  2. Walmart Original HP

    Seller: Walmart.com

    Checked yesterday: September 27, 2026

    $23.92

    Shipping unknown

    23.9¢/page

    View offer
  3. HP Store Original HP

    Checked yesterday: September 27, 2026

    $23.99

    Free shipping

    24.0¢/page

    View offer
  4. Target Original HP

    Price at retailer

    View offer
  5. Amazon.com Original HP

    Price at retailer

    View offer

HP 67XL tri-color (3YM58AN)

Comparison of 3 retailers with a checked price. Shipping is unknown for at least one retailer, so the ranking uses the product price before shipping. Prices are before sales tax, which depends on your state.
  1. Staples Original HP Lowest checked product price

    Checked yesterday: September 27, 2026

    $36.89

    Shipping unknown

    18.4¢/page

    View offer
  2. Walmart Original HP

    Seller: Walmart.com

    Checked yesterday: September 27, 2026

    $36.92

    Shipping unknown

    18.5¢/page

    View offer
  3. HP Store Original HP

    Checked yesterday: September 27, 2026

    $36.99

    Free shipping

    18.5¢/page

    View offer
  4. Target Original HP

    Price at retailer

    View offer
  5. Amazon.com Original HP

    Price at retailer

    View offer

Advertising disclosure: Some links on this website are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commission never affects the order of prices. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See how retailer links work.

Remanufactured and compatible alternatives

The comparison below is limited to this color position. Each badge states whether the seller explicitly calls the product remanufactured or only compatible.

Original HP reference offers

Direct, checked original offers for a like-for-like check. Compatible and remanufactured products stay separate below.

Original HP
Yield = the seller's own figure (not tested by 67ink.com). Comparison = the same composition in Original HP 67XL cartridges at the lowest checked price.
Product Stated pages Price Original HP 67XL, same composition Retailer
No alternative with a stated page yield has been checked in this market yet.

Also on sale, without a stated page yield

The seller gives no page yield; we don't convert milliliters into pages, so there's no cost comparison.

  • onn. remanufactured 67XL high-yield Tri-color Remanufactured Walmart's own onn. brand, sold by Walmart.com. $23.84 At Walmart
  • DoorStepInk remanufactured 67 Tri-color (made in the USA) Remanufactured $11.99 At Walmart

HP 67 tri-color questions

Should I buy HP 67 or HP 67XL?

67 and 67XL fit the same printers and print equally well. The difference is the amount of ink: HP states about 120 pages (black) and 100 pages (tri-color) for the standard cartridges, and about 240 and 200 pages for the XL versions (ISO/IEC 24711, continuous printing). Whether XL is cheaper per page depends only on the current price divided by that yield — we work that out with the prices checked now, not with a rule of thumb.

Can I use an HP 67 and an HP 67XL in the same printer?

Yes. The printer checks each position (black or tri-color) for a valid cartridge; standard or XL makes no difference to it. A common combination is XL for the color you use up fastest and standard for the other — HP even sells that pairing as one box (3YP30AN: 67XL Black + 67 Tri-color).

Is the HP 67 2-pack (3YP29AN) cheaper than two single cartridges?

The official 2-pack 3YP29AN contains one standard black and one standard tri-color cartridge. Whether it's cheaper than buying them separately depends on the current pack price versus the sum of the single prices — compare both before you buy. HP doesn't sell an HP 67XL 2-pack in the US; its US-only combo 3YP30AN pairs one 67XL Black with one standard 67 Tri-color.

How do I work out the cost per page of an HP 67 cartridge?

Cost per page = cartridge price ÷ stated page yield. For HP 67 Black (3YM56AN, about 120 pages) and HP 67XL Black (3YM57AN, about 240 pages), divide each current price by its yield. HP's yield is an average under ISO/IEC 24711 with continuous printing; with occasional printing or lots of color photos your real yield can differ.

Will I always get HP 67's stated page yield?

Not necessarily. HP's figure (120/100/240/200 pages) is an average measured under ISO/IEC 24711 by printing a test document continuously. Occasional printing, cleaning cycles after long idle periods and pages with heavy color coverage all reduce the real yield compared with HP's figure.

Sources (3)

Facts from HP and standards bodies are labeled as such. Calculations (cost per page and annual cost) are estimates by the 67ink.com editorial team. Last reconciled on .