Skip to main content
67ink.com

Compatible

Compatible HP 67 Ink: Prices, Yields & What to Check

Compare selected compatible HP 67/67XL listings from CompAndSave, Castle Ink and Walmart with Original HP. Check standard and XL separately, along with each seller's yield, chip information and returns.

Content updated:

  • CompAndSave HP 67XL Black: $18.95 for about 240 black pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67XL currently cost $35.89 for 240 black pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.
  • CompAndSave HP 67 Black: $18.95 for about 120 black pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67 currently cost $22.89 for 120 black pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.
  • CompAndSave HP 67XL Tri-color: $19.95 for about 200 color pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67XL currently cost $36.89 for 200 color pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.
  • CompAndSave HP 67 Tri-color: $19.95 for about 100 color pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67 currently cost $23.89 for 100 color pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.
  • Castle Ink compatible HP 67XL Black: $32.95 for about 240 black pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67XL currently cost $35.89 for 240 black pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.
  • Castle Ink compatible HP 67XL Tri-color: $34.95 for about 200 color pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67XL currently cost $36.89 for 200 color pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.
  • CompAndSave HP 67XL Black + 67XL Tri-color 2-pack: $35.90 for about 240 black + 200 color pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67XL currently cost $72.78 for 240 black + 200 color pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.
  • Castle Ink compatible HP 67XL Black + Tri-color 2-pack: $59.95 for about 240 black + 200 color pages (seller's figure) — the same cartridge counts in Original HP 67XL currently cost $72.78 for 240 black + 200 color pages (HP). Product prices exclude shipping and tax; seller and HP yield methods may differ.

Original HP reference offers

Direct, checked original offers for a like-for-like check. Compatible products stay separate below.

Original HP
Yield = the seller's own figure (not tested by 67ink.com). Comparison = the same composition in Original HP 67/67XL cartridges at the lowest checked price.
Product Stated pages Price Original HP 67/67XL, same composition Retailer
CompAndSave HP 67XL Black Compatible 1× black · compatible black 240 $18.95 checked November 13, 2026 $35.89 HP 67XL black 240 pages At CompAndSave
CompAndSave HP 67 Black Compatible 1× black · compatible black 120 $18.95 checked November 13, 2026 $22.89 HP 67 black 120 pages At CompAndSave
CompAndSave HP 67XL Tri-color Compatible 1× tri-color · compatible color 200 $19.95 checked November 13, 2026 $36.89 HP 67XL color 200 pages At CompAndSave
CompAndSave HP 67 Tri-color Compatible 1× tri-color · compatible color 100 $19.95 checked November 13, 2026 $23.89 HP 67 color 100 pages At CompAndSave
Castle Ink compatible HP 67XL Black Compatible 1× black · compatible Castle Ink states that the cartridges retain original HP chips. This is a seller claim, not a recognition test by 67ink.com. black 240 $32.95 checked November 13, 2026 $35.89 HP 67XL black 240 pages At Castle Ink
Castle Ink compatible HP 67XL Tri-color Compatible 1× tri-color · compatible Castle Ink states that the cartridges retain original HP chips. This is a seller claim, not a recognition test by 67ink.com. color 200 $34.95 checked November 13, 2026 $36.89 HP 67XL color 200 pages At Castle Ink
CompAndSave HP 67XL Black + 67XL Tri-color 2-pack Compatible 1× black + 1× tri-color · compatible black 240 · color 200 $35.90 checked November 13, 2026 $72.78 HP 67XL black 240 · color 200 pages At CompAndSave
Castle Ink compatible HP 67XL Black + Tri-color 2-pack Compatible 1× black + 1× tri-color · compatible Castle Ink states that the cartridges retain original HP chips. This is a seller claim, not a recognition test by 67ink.com. black 240 · color 200 $59.95 checked November 13, 2026 $72.78 HP 67XL black 240 · color 200 pages At Castle Ink
DoorStepInk remanufactured 67XXL Black + Tri-color Compatible 1× black + 1× tri-color · compatible black 400 · color 200 Price at retailer $72.78 HP 67XL black 240 · color 200 pages At Walmart
Also on sale, without a stated page yield The seller gives no page yield; we don't convert milliliters into pages, so there's no cost comparison.
Product Stated pages Price Original HP 67/67XL, same composition Retailer
onn. remanufactured 67XL high-yield Black Compatible Walmart's own onn. brand, sold by Walmart.com. n/a Price at retailer n/a At Walmart
onn. remanufactured 67XL high-yield Tri-color Compatible Walmart's own onn. brand, sold by Walmart.com. n/a Price at retailer n/a At Walmart
DoorStepInk remanufactured 67 Black (made in the USA) Compatible n/a Price at retailer n/a At Walmart
DoorStepInk remanufactured 67 Tri-color (made in the USA) Compatible n/a Price at retailer n/a At Walmart

CompAndSave covers standard and XL cartridges; Castle Ink adds a separate XL supplier. Walmart listings remain available without a numeric price when their previous observation has expired. Each price carries its own check date.

What does compatible mean?

A compatible cartridge is made or rebuilt by a company other than HP and sold for HP 67 printers. "Compatible", "generic", "store brand" and "remanufactured" aren't the same technical category: a remanufactured cartridge uses a used HP shell, a newly made compatible doesn't. So judge the actual product, not the label.

Walmart sells its own onn. brand 67XL cartridges and DoorStepInk's HP 67 cartridges as remanufactured. Neither listing describes the chip. CompAndSave lists approximate yields for its individual cartridges and two-XL set; the DoorStepInk 67XXL set also has seller-stated yields. These are seller figures, not measurements by this site or evidence of HP's test method.

Five things to check before you buy

  1. Exact printer model. "For HP 67" is weaker than a list that includes your model variant.
  2. Black or tri-color. Check which position you're replacing and which part number is the reference.
  3. Electronic chip. Does the seller explain which chip is used and what happens after a firmware update?
  4. Returns and warranty. A clear policy for a cartridge that isn't recognized reduces your risk.
  5. Where the yield claim comes from. A big number on the box isn't a test. The figures in the table above come from the seller.

Dynamic security

On the HP Store US product pages of the DeskJet 2855e, DeskJet 4255e and ENVY 6455e, among others, HP states that these printers are intended only for cartridges with new or reused HP electronic circuitry, and that firmware updates can block cartridges that worked before. A remanufactured cartridge with a reused HP chip fits that description; a cartridge with its own chip does not. So the outcome depends on the electronics and the printer firmware, not just the shell.

Compatible HP 67 questions

Is a compatible HP 67 cartridge safe for my printer?

A compatible or remanufactured cartridge comes from a company other than HP and is made to fit the same printer. Its yield, chip and compatibility claims are the seller's statements, not facts confirmed by HP, and 67ink.com hasn't tested them. HP's dynamic security may apply depending on your printer model; check this before you buy.

Can firmware affect compatible cartridges?

Yes. HP Store US states dynamic security on the product pages of the DeskJet 2855e, DeskJet 4255e and ENVY 6455e, among others: these printers are intended only for cartridges with new or reused HP electronic circuitry, and periodic firmware updates can block cartridges that worked before. Whether an alternative keeps working therefore depends on its chip and on future updates.

How do I judge a compatible cartridge without test data?

Check the seller, the exact list of printer models, chip information, warranty, returns and how open they are about the contents. Don't treat a yield claim as an independently proven result.

What's the difference between compatible and remanufactured?

'Compatible' is a broad label for an alternative, often newly made. Remanufactured means a returned cartridge shell has been cleaned and refilled. The onn. and DoorStepInk HP 67 cartridges on Walmart.com, for example, are sold as remanufactured. What exactly a seller supplies should be stated on the product page.

Can I combine original black with a compatible color cartridge?

The positions work independently, but whether a particular alternative works still depends on the product and printer. Check the model claim and the seller's returns policy.

Sources (5)

Facts from HP and standards bodies are labeled as such. Calculations (cost per page and annual cost) are estimates by the 67ink.com editorial team. Last reconciled on .